Granite vs. Quartz Countertops: Which Should You Choose?

The perfect countertop is the icing on the cake for a kitchen remodel. Choosing the right countertop material, color and finish can transform your kitchen from good to great. But what if you can’t decide between two popular, high-end options: granite and quartz? We’re here to help you break down the granite vs. quartz countertops dilemma so you can choose which option is best for your kitchen.

The Difference Between Granite vs. Quartz Countertops

If you’ve come this far, you probably like the look of both types of countertops. From the surface, granite and quartz have similarities: they’re equally beautiful, functional, and trendy. But understanding the pros and cons of each is a great way to pick the right countertop for you.

Granite Countertop Pros and Cons

Granite is a natural stone that comes directly from stone quarries. Granite has been popular for many years and continues to be a smart choice for kitchen remodels.

Pros

• Versatility: For an elegant look, go with the shiny appearance of polished granite. If you prefer something more subtle, consider honed granite, which has a matte finish with little to no shine.
• Toughness: Both polished and honed granite are resistant to chipping, scratching, and heat, so they’re fantastic options in the kitchen.
• Uniqueness: As we mentioned, since granite comes from the earth, its colors and patterns are unique to each slab. You won’t find another piece of granite that looks exactly like the one you select for your kitchen — making your space one-of-a-kind.
• Appearance: People continue to love granite because it’s stunning. Whether you’re going for a modern look or something more traditional, you’re sure to find a granite slab that fits your kitchen’s style.

Cons

• Higher maintenance: Since granite is natural stone, it’s more porous than man-made quartz. To keep it protected from stains and spills, you must seal it periodically.
• More environmental impact: Using granite for countertops requires quarrying, which affects the environment.
• Can be costly: Granite prices are comparable to quartz since it’s also considered a high-end countertop material. You can expect to pay anywhere from $80 to $175 per square foot, installed.

Quartz Countertop Pros and Cons

Quartz is one of our favorite countertop materials. Our clients often choose quartz for kitchen islands or under-cabinet surfaces — it’s a popular option and we foresee its popularity for years to come.

Pros

• Durability: If you want something low-maintenance, quartz is the way to go because it’s durable and long-lasting. It can withstand harsh circumstances that working in a kitchen sometimes produces, like hot pans, chopping vegetables, or sliding plates.
• Mess-resistant: The quartz surface is non-porous, meaning it won’t soak up spilled liquids or harbor bacteria.
• Resilience: Don’t worry about damaging quartz countertops: they’re resistant to dents, scratches, and stains.
• Beauty: One of the reasons quartz is so popular is because it comes in a variety of beautiful patterns, designs, and colors. From simple to elaborate, there’s something for everyone.

Cons

• Can be pricey: Quartz is one of the higher-end, more expensive countertop materials. The price depends on which brand and style of quartz you choose. The average quartz countertop costs anywhere from $80 to $140 per square foot, installed.
• Fewer design variations: Keep in mind that quartz is engineered, or man-made, stone. So if you want the look of natural stone with uniqueness and plenty of veining and waves, it’s harder to find that with quartz.

Whether you decide to go with quartz or granite countertops, you can’t go wrong with either. Both options are fantastic ways to update your kitchen and increase your home’s value. Since both are high-end countertop materials, you’re sure to love whichever option you choose. And if you have any other questions about granite vs. quartz countertops, we’re here to help.

Learn More About Granite & Quartz Countertops

Every home deserves a kitchen that’s beautiful, welcoming, and functional — designed for the way you live. Established by two long-time central Ohio homebuilders and craftsmen, The Creative Kitchen Co. offers customized kitchen remodeling and refacing solutions. Get in touch to learn more about our granite and quartz countertop solutions.